Skip to content


Sauce tomatoes versus slicing tomatoes: does the difference matter?

One way of categorizing home-grown tomatoes is dividing them into tomatoes for cooking and making sauce and tomatoes for slicing and eating fresh. Are the categories really that different? I think the answer is both yes and no.

For slicing and eating fresh, many people recommend Brandywine, Mortgage Lifter, Cherokee Purple, Black Krim, or Beefsteak tomatoes. These are among our favorites for BLTs, simple tomato salads, or slicing and eating with a bit of salt and herbs.

For the most part, slicing tomatoes are roundish in shape and large, although sizes may vary. These tomatoes are generally quite juicy.

When we make sauce, we like to use Amish paste, San Marzano or Roma tomatoes. Sauce or paste tomatoes tend to be more oval, or oblong, or pear-shaped. They are also considered to be “dryer” having less liquid and more pulp than slicing tomatoes.

Although I tend to use tomatoes along these categories, I’m not hard-edged about it. Some cooks swear by a certain tomato for a particular use, but I like to mix varieties for a more complex taste, whether in making tomato sauce– or apple sauce or pie, for that matter.

Overall, I would argue that home-grown tomatoes are pretty interchangeable (grocery store tomatoes, for the most part, are only worth eating in desperation in January no matter how they are prepared.) Sauce tomatoes will do for a salad or BLT in my book, and big juicy slicing tomatoes also make good sauce, although they will take significantly longer to cook down.

When preparing sauce using tomatoes that have a lot of juice or seeds, you can speed up the cooking process by seeding the tomatoes before cooking. The easiest way I’ve found to do this is the cut the tomato in half along on the equator, as it were, and then gently squeeze with one hand while gently prodding the tomato cavities with a finger. I don’t obsess over seed removal because I run tomato sauce through the food mill after cooking to make a smooth sauce.

The tomatoes are still ripening in our garden, so I’m looking forward to more meals of fresh and cooked homegrown tomatoes. We planted some new-to-us varieties this year, and I was a little uncertain about which was which. The fun and informative Ann Arbor Farmers’ Market blog contained a link to a guide to tomato varieties on Rutgers New Jersey Agricultural Experiment Station, so I have been able to identify the varieties we planted that I’ve been unsure about.

Our home-made tomato sauce has the potential of including about a dozen varieties of tomatoes. I’m not a purist, however, I know our tomato sauce will be red, delicious– and plentiful, I hope.

How selective are you about the ways you use slicing or sauce tomatoes?

Posted in • Growing.


0 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

You must be logged in to post a comment.